Click on the above to visit our featured advertisers. Tell them you saw their ad on Wiring for DCC!
This is Part I. Go to Part II.
Please read this introduction!
There have been significant changes to this particular web page!
There are several sections in this website that you should read regarding track wiring. This section on track wiring, Part I, covers general wiring information, testing, and troubleshooting. Part II contains the actual wiring of track. The menu to the right will automatically take you to the right section.
Connecting your track to your booster is covered in Booster
Network Wiring. Wiring your turnouts also
has its own section. Be sure to become familiar with all these sections.
They have recently been expanded to cover topics that are frequently
asked on the DCC
Q&A forum. Finally, you may find the section
on track and wire resistance interesting.
SUGGESTION: Buy Several Boxes of Different Colored Push Pins.
These are cheap, sanity saving devices. Use one color to mark rail "A". Use another color to indicate that a section of track has been wired. Use another to indicate a problem rail switch to the track gang.
Use a 3156 or 1156 Automotive Taillight Bulb to Limit Current to a Track Sub Bus.
The 1156 taillight bulb has been around for years, but it is starting to get scarce. The new version of the 1156 is the 3156. The science is the same for both bulbs, so read what I have below. Then I wrote about the 3156 and using it. Also, before I get into taillight bulbs, I write about the increasingly popular LED.
Incadescent tail light bulbs may become hard to find. Also, you might like something that takes up less space. Check out these space-saving alternatives.
Can You Use an LED Instead of a Bulb?
Unfortunately not. A light bulb works because its resistance increases when it heats up and lights. This increased resistance is how a light bulb limits a short. The resistance of an LED does not increase when it heats up. So it won't work.
If you are tempted to try it anyway, you will find that the LED will not allow your locomotive to properly receive the DCC signal and power. Your locomotive will not run properly. Furthermore, if you have a short, your LED will burn out very quickly.
Should You Use Taillight Bulbs, Circuit Breakers, or Neither???
The use of light bulbs to limit current has been occurring long before I was born. Heck, even the use of car taillight bulbs in model trains wasn't my idea. Since the bulbs I saw in an old Model Railroader were all obsolete, I ran tests and determined that the very low cost #1156 was the optimal choice. Other than publishing my findings here in my web page, I would have expected this to be the extent of my contribution to the hobby on this topic. Instead, I've not only evidently sold tons of bulbs — with not a bit of thanks from the bulb manufacturers! — but the topic continues to generate a ton of email on the Internet. Since the topic is still not clearly understood by all, I thought I'd come back and rewrite things and try to do a better job by adding a few things that have been learned over the past few years.
Why use taillight bulbs? A taillight bulb is a low cost way to limit current when a short occurs on your layout. Shorts typically occur when a train derails or when points and wheel sets are out of tolerance and touch. When bulbs are used to supply power to a sub bus, only that sub bus will be affected. The train(s) in that sub bus will stop. Any other trains attached to that same booster will not. As an extra bonus, the bright light provides quick localization to a short — it lights up your feet!
Why use bulbs? Why do they work regarding shorts? A light bulb is cheap and seemingly simple. Why use them to limit current in shorts? What makes them work?
A light bulb when it is off and cool has a very low resistance. If this was all there was to a light bulb, it would be useless in protecting shorts. However, its very low resistance allows the train to receive nearly full voltage and current. So when there is no short it is as if the bulb was nothing more than a piece of wire.
When a short occurs, a much higher amount of current attempts to flow to your track. This much higher current causes the light bulb to light. This is where the important thing happens. The bulb is very hot when lit. The wire inside bulb has what is known as a positive temperature coefficient. When the temperature goes up so does the resistance of the bulb. The resistance of the bulb now has a much higher resistance than when it was cold. This higher resistance limits the current to the short.
When the short goes away, the current flowing through the bulb drops off. The bulb cools. It goes back to having a very low resistance and your train runs again.
It is not the intent of this website to talk you out of buying circuit breakers. Since the bulbs are much less expensive than electronic circuit breakers, you can afford to have more of them. This allows you to sub divide your layout into smaller electrical pieces in an effort to more quickly localize a short when one occurs. This is why I and others use bulbs instead of circuit breakers. It's a choice you have and thought you might like to know about it!
sure the bulb doesn't touch anything. It gets hot when it comes
on. You don't want to risk fire. It is cold when the bulb
is not lit.
Taillight bulbs do not make shorts go away. If a short takes place, you will have to resolve it right then and there — just as you would if you didn't use them. The same goes for circuit breakers.
I must warn you, however. There will still be a lot of current flowing through the short, as well as all the wires and trackwork leading up to the short. Enough heat can be generated to melt ties and do some minor welding. The group I am associated with has wooden ties. We haven't had any side effects like welding or melting, but I understand that it has happened to some people, so I felt you should be fairly warned.
So you may want to put a switch in series with the bulb. As soon as a short develops, you can hit the switch. I personally don't bother with switches. If I'm worried about melting, burning, or damaging anything I would hit the master kill on my DCC throttle. You will rarely feel the need to do this.
Do you have to use taillight bulbs or circuit breakers? Positively, absolutely, not. The use of either the bulb or the circuit breaker is simply to subdivide a layout into smaller electrical pieces for easier troubleshooting. Also, when a short triggers either of these devices, only trains in that smaller electrical section are affected. Not using either of these devices simply means a bigger portion of your layout will shut down when a short takes place. This is hardly a catastrophe.
So why did I ever bother looking into taillight bulbs? Before command control of any kind, not just DCC, derailments took place, but they only affected one train, one operator, and one power pack. No one thought anything of it. This is how it had always been since my first train set!
But when a club I was in went DCC, every short shut down the entire layout. (The DCC system we were using at the time compounded the problem by sending a shutdown command to all boosters, whether that booster was truly affected or not.) Three or four shorts an operating session per each of the fifteen or so operators meant the entire layout was shutting down an average of every three minutes. People were rapidly getting disgusted with DCC!
With ancient, inconsistent, undocumented, and in some cases, incorrect wiring, as well as turnouts and things that weren't in gauge any more, finding the source of the shutdown never had us shutdown less than five minutes and usually more like fifteen. Without electronic circuit breakers available at the time and the bank already broken outfitting the large layout with DCC, I went after the age old solution of taillight bulbs before a posse went and lynched the DCC equipment manufacturer.
A few years later I joined a club that had just gone with a non-DCC command control. History repeated itself. Now a veteran of the taillight, I showed up the next week with a fist full of fixes.
Should you use taillight bulbs or circuit breakers? This is perhaps the most important question you need to answer for yourself. The more boosters you can afford to have, resulting in a layout that is broken up into smaller electrical sections (known as booster districts), the less you will have a need for either bulbs or circuit breakers. The fewer operators and trains you have, the less likely an aggravating short will take place. The more perfect your trackwork, turnouts, rolling stock, and locomotives are in, the less likely you will have a short. Now if you could only keep momentarily inattentive operators from trying to run through a turnout thrown against them!
The majority of shorts occur at turnouts. Avoid minor welding, melting ties, and lighting that bulb, or tripping the circuit breaker or booster; use DCC friendly turnouts if you can. The use of DCC friendly turnouts, discussed in the turnout section of this web page, is not required. It is simply another choice you have as a modeler.
The clubs I have been in and their members have come to love the bulbs. Members building layouts at home are building the bulbs in from the start. They like the ease of troubleshooting the bulbs provide and they really like the floor lighting up in the vicinity of the problem.
The choice of either or neither is completely yours. This web page simply wants you to know your choices.
Can you add them later? Yes. If you think you might, then seriously consider putting in sub buses now. This is especially true if you might use bulbs. If you don't, it will definitely be much more difficult, but not impossible, to add breakers or bulbs later.
How long your sub buses are, is not nearly as important as installing them in the first place. You will have to add sub buses in some way to use bulbs. You can always cut sub buses in half. Especially if you want to use bulbs, where very short sub buses are part of the attraction to using bulbs, look at the layout wiring diagrams in this web page to understand the usage of sub buses.
Do taillight bulbs always work? No. Most manufacturers of modern boosters will shut down before the taillight will activate.
Fast Acting Boosters:
Lighted Passenger Trains:
Boosters That Are Running Within About 2-3 Amps of
Their Rated Capacity:
Working On The Various Scales:
G scale: Do not use bulbs for G scale. You probably don't have so many trains and operators that this would be an issue for you anyway.
O and S: Bulbs will probably only work with O and S scale locomotives with high quality motors.
HO: Of course! If you have double headed trains, you shouldn't have trouble using bulbs. Triple or more may light the bulb. High quality locos, low or no grade, and more locos than cars :) may work fine.
N, Z: You can probably lash five locomotives together. One word of caution when using bulbs for these smaller scales. As noted earlier, bulbs do not cut stop the short, they merely limit the amount of current below the trip threshold of the boosters. But these currents are still fairly high for the small components in these smaller scales. Melted or otherwise damaged parts are entirely possible. The operating environments that N and particular Z are used in may not even make bulbs an appealing option to be considered.
Can you use taillights and circuit breakers? Probably not. You probably wouldn't want to anyway. They both serve the same goal — to limit the amount of a layout affected when a short occurs.
Should you use sockets with these bulbs? The cheapest socket I could find for these bulbs was $4. Tail light bulbs are designed to go on and off a zillion times. If you used DCC friendly turnouts and laid your track well, hopefully these bulbs will light infrequently and last a lifetime. I received an email saying someone installed them in the 50's on his layout and has yet to burn one out.
One reason to use a socket is if you plan to use the bulb as a switch - that is, if you plan to remove the bulb to isolate a section of track. A switch and the socket are essentially the same price so go for it. Since I use micro switches with Switchmaster turnout machines and slide on lugs for the micro switch, I can just slide the lug off the micro switch to act as a switch.
Make sure the bulb doesn't touch anything. It gets hot. You don't want to risk fire.
If you want to buy a socket for the 1156, one of my readers found an inexpensive socket. See See the section on Getting Electronic Parts.
Reader Ed Collins makes his bulb mounts as follows: He just took a standard #6 spade. Took a punch and opened up the slot on the end you solder the wire in. Flattened it out, drilled a small hole large enough to get the pin on the side of the 1156 bulb into it. Solder the spade on the side of the bulb. Works fine and you do not have to try and buy a special connector.
Digitrax Chief Owners: You will have to set the Chief option #18 to 'closed.' This causes the DCS100 to delay for 1/2 second before reacting to a short circuit, rather than the 1/8 second it comes set to from the factory.
If you came here from the section on wiring turnouts, click here to return to wiring turnouts.
Are They Hard to Find? This bulb isn't as popular in cars as it used to be. While you can still get them at auto supply stores and discount stores automotive departments, you may want to try D. Erwin's suggestion. He tells me http://www.sunraylighting.com will sell in bulk and at wholesale.
The 3156 is the modern version of the 1156. As you can see from the photo, the 3156 uses a plastic base instead of a metal one. On the right side of the photo, you can see that the 3156 has a wire termination. There is another wire on the other side.
You can bend these terminations and remove the plastic base. You will need to pull firmly to remove the plastic base. Keep pulling. It will come free. You can then slide the terminations under the screw of a terminal strip. That's good because the metal blade (the "3/4 W solder terminal series 140") that I used on the 1156's is now obsolete and no longer available. And of course, you don't have to spend any additonal money for mounting the 3156. You may need to trim the leads a little bit before securing them to a terminal strip.
Alternatives to Car Tail Light Bulbs
Tail light bulbs are a low cost way of limiting short circuit currents. As car manufacturers embrace LED technology, incadescent tail light bulbs will become increasingly difficult to find. Tail light bulbs have another big disadvantage with big being the operative word. They are big and take up a lot of space under a layout. So if you want an alternative to tail light bulbs, these products may interest you.
Be sure to read the section above on tail light bulbs as the same pros and cons exist. For example, they only work with systems that react slowly (about a half-second) to shorts and do not interrupt the current flow completely like electronic circuit breakers.
Due to slower reaction time of these devices, they may not work with all systems. Some systems have configurable reaction times. So you may have to select the extended or longer reaction times. Consult your system's manual. I suggest you buy one of these devices and try it out before you buy however many you will need.
SUGGESTION: Attach Your Sub Bus Feeders With Screw Terminals.
If you have a short that is troublesome to find, you will be able to disconnect the feeders. Otherwise.... you will have to start cutting your carefully soldered wires. I've seen this happen more than once, I'm afraid. I prefer soldered connections, too. But here, soldering will work against your troubleshooting efforts.
The following two drawing show how I like to anchor the ends of the sub buses as well as attach to the main bus. The first arrangement shows if you are using bulbs. It could be a DCC circuit breaker. The second shows the use of a block detector and a bulb. These are just ideas that you can use for seeds for your own desired arrangement.
Do note that this arrangement causes the block to be fed from one end. If you are using heavy wire and short blocks, this works well. For example, my blocks are no longer than 15 feet long and I use #14 or #12 wire for sub buses. The 15 foot length is simply so I can detect a train every 15 feet. You could probably double this without any noticeable affect on your train operations.
It has the physical advantage of providing a place to anchor the end of each block — no loose ends. Also, you precisely know where one block ends and the next begins.
SUGGESTION: Develop A Color Code - And Stick To It!
If you have to make a trip back to your favorite home improvement store to get more wire, do it! Your sanity is at stake here!
In fact, let me suggest a color code based on the fact that many of you may want to use regular house wiring. White for the "common" bus feed. Remember common bus feeds between booster districts are NOT to be connected together! Black for your main bus. Clear or green for your sub buses. See the schematics and read on for clarification.
If you use the bare copper wire as part of your feeder system, be careful it doesn't contact anything that is grounded to your home wiring. Worse, beware of contacting any other voltage sources — such as the wires going to your booster power transformer that perhaps you haven't gotten around to putting in a box.
SUGGESTION: Get Your Wire From Your Favorite Home Improvement Store.
This has its advantages. Probably the most important one is that if you run out, you can easily get more wire. This convenience will help you stick to your color code scheme. Also, the price may be more reasonable than any electronic supply store.
At a home improvement store you can find:
Heavy stranded wire. At Home Depot, they stock:
14 AWG: Blk Beige Red Blu Grn Wht
12 AWG: Blk Red(Rose) Wht Blu Org Yel Brn Grn
10 AWG: Brn Org Yel Blk Red Blu Wht
Heavy solid wire for wiring homes. This stuff
is cheap, so may want to base your power distribution
Light solid wire for wiring phones and thermostats.
Telephone wire is the thinnest solid wire available. It only comes in 4 conductors. It could be used for your booster network where you are running a separate heavy ground. Telephone wire is red, black, yellow, and green.
Thermostat wire is solid and available in 4, 6, and 8 conductors. So you may want to use this for running LocoNet and particularly the booster network. It is heavier than telephone wire, so it is less likely to break. The 4 color wire is red, green, white, and yellow.
Antenna rotor (or rotator) wire is stranded. It is also available from Radio Shack. It comes in 4, 5, and 8 conductors. It is generally not color coded.
Heavy duty color coded antenna rotor wire is available from amateur radio supply stores. Ask a ham radio operator where one of these is or when the next hamfest is. If you don't know a ham, don't worry about using this type of wire.
While there is a lot to be said for stranded wire, if you use the brown ribbon antenna rotor variety, you may have a difficult time figuring out which edge of the ribbon is the first wire under a dimly lit layout.
SUGGESTION: Good Track Connection Practices Come First.
Make sure you lay your track and join rails together in a manner that you think is the right way. I don't know that I really should get into this since I haven't lived long enough to see all the ways it could be done and how well they hold up.
Some people don't solder switches in place so they are easy to remove if they need any work.
Some people don't like to solder too many pieces of track together due to expansion considerations. You definitely need to consider the temperature swing in your layout room. Is it in the house or out in the garage?
So after deciding what your track laying practices are going to be, follow this basic rule: Every piece of track should be soldered to something. That can be another piece of track or a wire. The wire can be a feeder or a jumper from the adjacent rail. DO NOT count on a metal joiner to carry power to the next rail. It WILL let you down eventually. I expect you knew that already.
SUGGESTION: Using Insulation Displacement Connectors (IDC).
An article by Tony Koester in the August 1998 Model Railroader discussed using insulation displacement connectors. These are commonly used for installing aftermarket automotive products like car alarms. Frequently they are used to clip onto existing wires for power and ground. Not surprisingly, someone might want to use them to connect to DCC power busses.
An insulation displacement connector is a type of connector that has a fork with a knife edge. It can pierce a wire's insulation and make good electrical contact with the encased wire. There is no need to strip a wire and the connection can be made in a second.
This type of connection has been used by phone companies for several decades. Their reliability, WHEN USED PROPERLY, has been proven.
Using them properly, requires that you do these things:
1. You MUST use the proper one for the wire sizes you will be using. If you are using one that is too small for your wire, it may bite into the wire too much. It might then break. If too large, a poor or non-permanent connection may be made.
2. If you must unclamp the IDC, do not reclamp it exactly where it was previously. When clamped, it must clamp onto a fresh location. This location does not need to be far. The location of the bite need only be a fresh one. An 1/8" or 2mm is adequate.
3. Use the tool 3M makes for squeezing the IDC around the wire. Based on reader experience, this seems critical. Trying to save a few dollars and using a pair of pliers results in IDCs that fail.
Do NOT tug any wire or allow any strain to be imparted onto a wire attached using an IDC. There is no way for me to say how much is too much. At one extreme, you have the telephone application, where the cabling is installed and virtually never touched. Works great. At the other extreme, you have fragile computer ribbon cables that are occasionally misapplied to save money in applications where the cable may be moved several dozen or more times. They fail. Ribbon cables inside computers generally do okay if the person is mindful of them.
It is almost inevitable in the life of a layout that some tugging to troubleshoot a problem will be done. Or maybe you will need to add or remove some track necessitating the need to tug on wires. Or, in pulling new wires, they get slightly wrapped around existing wires and some strain is imparted.
You may find yourself having to disconnect feeders should you have to troubleshoot shorts. Do not reattach in exactly the same place on the wires.
As long as you heed my cautions, using IDCs should work well for you. With some strain inevitable, it is difficult to say if you will start having problems several years from now.
These connectors are easy to install and may be ideal for someone who hasn't developed the knack for soldering.
Soldering is still the best connection possible. If you don't mind soldering, then stay with soldering. If nothing else, soldering is cheaper.
One advantage of terminal blocks is that they force a certain amount of neatness. They can be rigidly mounted in a fixed location (you always know where it is) and it can be labeled. A splice, IDC, solder, or any other type of "floating" connection (its location may change whenever it is tugged) has minimal labeling (wrapped around the wire) if labeled at all.
The photo of the IDCs in Model Railroader show the advantage of a floating connection. It is close to where it is needed. It MIGHT not need any labeling at all.
You can carry the floating connections too far. Even though it seemed like a good idea at the time you did your installation, you can easily end up with a unbelievable mess. You may have to do a lot tugging to find out where wires go to or come from. If using IDCs, lots of tugging is the last thing you want.
Use terminal strips where you would have used them whether or not you used IDCs.
Label your wires. Any label at all that provides unique identification of a wire is better than no label at all. Label the wire frequently so you don't have to do a lot tugging. Labels at both ends of a 20' long wire do you no good when you are in the middle! Every other joist is good.
Avoid chaining. That is a IDC that is connected to a wire that is connected to an IDC that is connected to a wire.....that is connected to a bus. If you have a problem in this situation, it could be difficult to troubleshoot. Hold yourself to two IDCs or less between ANY track feed and a booster.
Also make sure your buses are continuous pieces of wire, mechanically well connected at joints, like well twisted and soldered, or use terminal strips. If using lugs on terminal strips, solder the wire to the lug. In lugs, even if the wire doesn't pull out, tugging on the connection could ultimately lead to a poor connection. Your bus wires are your most important wires! Make sure the quality of their connection to their sources (boosters) is without question! Make sure it acts likes a continuous piece of wire and can withstand tugging.
Where to buy IDCs:
IDCs are common in car radio installation kits. But they are not commonly used for home wiring or anything else. So you will have a hard time finding them in any store of any kind. Modelers have tried Radio Shack, auto stores, local electrical distributors and such. Your best bet is a mail-order electrical components distributor like Mouser. You will get the quantity you need at a good price as well as a variety of choices - necessary to make sure you use the right one for your application. See the section on Getting Electronic Parts for IDC part numbers and suppliers.
RECOMMENDATION: Build a Short Detecting Beeper BEFORE You Start ANY DCC Track Wiring!
It's no accident that this recommendation is the first in the track wiring section. If you wait until you find out you have shorts, it's too late. Don't wait until you wish you had made one of these. Do it now. It only takes a few minutes and a few dollars to put together.
Of course, Radio Shack is gone. You can get a buzzer from Jameco. Many buzzers will work. I selected one from Jameco that has leads and runs on a 9V battery. The Jameco part number is 2117430. Their part number for a 9V battery clip is 1949488, Then attach this instead of a booster to your track while doing all wiring. Any wiring error that you make that results in a short will cause an immediate beeeeeep. This is before you've soldered the wire or hooked up twenty feeders only to find nothing works! Use this thing religiously.
If you have several boosters, you will need to move the beeper to each booster district as you wire. Alternately, if you have a team wiring several districts at once, temporarily jumper the main booster feeders together so only one beeper is needed.
You could also mount the circuit in a bobber caboose or clip it to the track with alligator clips. Be sure the boosters are not connected to the track. I cannot emphasize this enough. The booster will appear as a short to the beeper. Nothing but the beeper should be attached to the track. This includes things like Frog Juicers and auto reversing controllers. These are great products, but you will need to install them last because they will all cause the buzzer to sound.
You can use a light bulb instead of a buzzer. Light bulbs are a less sensitive than the buzzer. But if you use a light bulb, be constantly looking at it. You can easily be wiring happily along and not notice the light.
Also note, do not use an LED if you are using Frog Juicers and electronic auto reversing controllers. Like the buzzer, and LEDs are very sensitive. If you do use LEDs, hook up the Frog Juicer and electronic auto reversing controllers last.
You can use an ohmmeter, but you will get squirelly results. So don't do this unless you have a very good understanding of exactly how an ohmmeter works.
For a club, you might want the following buzzer:
It is designed to have the buzzer attached to the track
whenever the DCC is not on. This is so people don't forget to use the
buzzer. C1 is 25V or higher 1000uF capacitor. R1 ohms = (Vbooster -
Vrelay)/Irelay. R1 wattage = (Vbooster - Vrelay) x Irelay. R1 may not
be needed at all as some relays will run fine at 14V without damage.
A Simple Test Indicator Light for DCC
Contributed by Don Vollrath
Many times during construction or troubleshooting there will be a need to verify if there is DCC voltage between the proper track rails as expected …or not… or if the polarity is reversed across gaps in the track, or if anything on the other side of the gap is even connected. One may be tempted to use a voltmeter or an LED type tester to help perform the task. However these instruments can sometimes be too sensitive and yield confusing results, particularly where long wire or track rails are involved. The simple reason is the continuous polarity switching of DCC voltage can cause a minute amount of ‘leakage’ current to flow even when something is seemingly unconnected. This can cause a sensitive LED to glow or an AC voltmeter to read something unexpected.
A more positive solution is to use a small incandescent bulb that draws significant amount of current for such testing. When an incandescent bulb needing more than 10 milli-amps (ma) is used there is no doubt that DCC voltage is or is not present between the two probed points. Either the bulb lights up or it doesn’t.
You can make your own probe using a 14V, 30ma bulb such as Miniatronics #18-014-10. A convenient ready made probe type tester with a clip on lead found in automotive parts stores under the BALKAMP brand draws about 200 ma on DCC power.
SUGGESTION: Measuring DCC Track Voltage and Current (Amperage)
Attention Master Model Railroaders: I have heard that measuring current is a requirement for achieving Master Model Railroad. Here's how to do it! Tony's Train Exchange makes a combination DCC ammeter and voltmeter.
First, let's discuss how we should refer to the voltage we measure. This is more for those already familiar with AC voltage measurements. If you are not, skip to the next paragraph so that you can measure your DCC track voltage and current.
AC is usually measured with qualifiers such as "rms", "average", "peak", and "peak-to-peak." DCC is square wave AC. What should we call it? Extreme few of us own "true-reading rms" meters, so forget rms. Only old analog meters, with a needle, read average. Peak and peak-to-peak refer to a ground reference. A decoder has no way of knowing any such reference. So do either of these have meaning to us? While technically, all these can be used to refer to DCC voltage, the only thing that really matters is what the absolute peak voltage applied across the input leads of a decoder. Many devices can be used with DCC. These often contain documentation that says "do not exceed 24 volts" or something to that effect.
So what I do is convert DCC to DC, to be measured by a standard DC voltmeter, and simply refer to it as volts. Technically, "peak" would be the applicable term. Use the circuit below to convert DCC to DC and follow the directions below.
This circuit assumes that you are using a digital volt meter with an input impedance of at least 1 mega ohm.
Should you build the average or peak reading circuit? Don Vollrath has the following suggestions for you.
The Average voltage detector should be used to measure and adjust the 'normal' DCC track voltage level. Use this for general track voltage measurements, anywhere on the layout, with and without track loads. Always useful to detect track voltage drops due to poor connections or poor DCC bus wiring.
The Peak detector is useful to help visualize how much voltage ringing is on the system, w/o having to use a multi-K-buck oscilloscope. If the peak V is >2X the average V, one should be adding R/C suppression networks to help prevent problems.
This circuit will convert DCC square wave AC to standard
DC. However, before you get excited and measuring DCC track voltage,
you need to calibrate this circuit. Here's how.
This circuit is a very slight variation on the above. It allows you to measure the amperage drawn by your DCC equipment. You could use the above circuit with the capacitor if you want to. Without the capacitor, you will get a more exact reading.
SUGGESTION: How to Know If Your Wiring is Adequate — The "Quarter Test"
All manufacturers will tell you, your wiring MUST pass this test: If you short your track at any point with a coin or tool, it MUST cause your booster to shutdown. If it does not do so consistently and everywhere on your layout you try, including powered frogs, your wiring is inadequate. Melted plastic is likely and a fire is definitely possible. Your steam trains and diesels with shot rings are the only things that should be smoking on your layout — not your benchwork and wiring! If you are using light bulbs as I suggest on this website, the light should light brightly. A half lit or dim bulb is a sign of inadequate wiring.
In order for this test to work, your booster must have an adequate power supply. Your booster must be supplied by a power supply that has a current rating equal to or greater than the booster's rating. If not, this test will not work. You may falsely think your booster is not working properly or your wiring is inadequate when the problem is really your power supply is too small. Do not use your old DC power pack to power your booster. It probably cannot put out enough power to operate your booster properly. See the section on booster network wiring.
If shorting your bus trips your booster but shorting your track does not, you have inadequate feeders. For those who know a little bit about electricity, you may be confused by measuring the bus voltage at the feeder under the layout and reading the same thing as you measure on your track. You might be led to think they everything is good. There is a little bit more about electricity that you need to know. Voltage only drops when you have a load. If you measure the track voltage with a load - such as an operating locomotive or a car tail light bulb - you will then see the voltage drop at your track. This is a little science fair project. Once you do it, you will learn that measuring the track voltage is not a good way of testing if your wiring is adequate. In summary, let me repeat, if shorting your bus at the bus/feeder connection trips your booster but shorting your track does not, you have inadequate feeders; bad connections to your track, bus, or both; or all of the above.
If you are using IDCs (insulation displacement connectors), you must be using the ones intended for the wire size you are using, they must be installed using the proper tools, and you cannot reuse them.
If you soldered your wires, did you get a good solder joint? It should have a nice, smooth finish, no brown residue, and no blob.
Did you solder your wires to the track and/or bus? No? That's your problem. Solder wires to your track. If not using IDCs on your buses, solder your feeders to your bus.
Are you using 24 AWG wire for your feeders? They must be short and frequent. You must pass the quarter test or your wiring is inadequate.
SUGGESTION: Use a Volt Meter to Check Your Track Polarity with the Beeper.
If you always use the beeper and are sure you hook it up the same way, a volt meter can help you verify that your "A" rail is really the "A" rail. Just hook up your beeper and then measure the voltage it produces with your voltmeter.
SUGGESTION: DCC Track Power Polarity Identification
DCC track power is a form of AC. But it helps you keep things straight while you wire if you keep thinking of it the same way as you did with DC. You still have two wires and you need to know which is which. This is especially important topside. With your layout winding every which way, it's easy to lose track.
Call them "+" and "-", "A" and "B", "Tarzan" and "Jane", whatever you like. Avoid "inside" and "outside" rail because unless you have a simple oval, chances are your inside rail will become your outside rail at some point.
Track Polarity Car
Here's a great visual aid if you have trouble keeping track of which rail and wire is which or if you are troubleshooting a wiring problem. You only may need one car if you are wiring your layout. If you are troubleshooting a wiring problem, two may be useful.
Paint the car any colors you want. You may find it to be a good idea to paint the car the same colors as your bus wires. You probably see where this is going. Five-finger the car around your layout and check your bus wires, if already installed, or install your bus wires as you go.
Any type of car will work as well as a cheap car that normally won't stay on the track.
Getting Frog Polarity Correct
How to quickly and easily get your frogs wired correctly. See the section on Switches.
TROUBLESHOOTING: Don't Waste Your Time Trying to Find a Short With an Ohm Meter.
It never works. I really wish it did! The typical ohm meter, digital ohm meter, etc. just isn't sensitive enough. Save you energy for doing it in a way that is guaranteed to get results. That is....tip # 5-21.
TROUBLESHOOTING: Train Does Not Operate Properly When Crossing Between Booster Districts.
Before you get started, be sure you are familar with what happens when trains cross between booster districts. This is covered in under reversing basics in the DCC for Beginner's section.
Below is a simple way to determine if all is well with your booster wiring when a locomotive goes from one booster district to the next. All you need is a 14V-16V (for HO) light bulb. Two boosters are shown below.
Note that the boosters are connected together with a ground wire. Either connect this to the ground connection on your booster, if there is one, or to the booster case if there is not. This ground wire should not be connected to the ground wire that connects to your home's wall socket (earth ground).
Your boosters receive their DCC signal from a network cable that connects between all the boosters and command station. Some manufacturers have a booster built into their command station.
One of the boosters can be in reversing mode. Both boosters should NEVER be in reversing mode at the same time. If they are, stop now, and make only one booster at most a reversing booster. Likewise, if you are using reversing units, the same thing applies.
Follow my directions below. Don't skip steps as each step will help you identify a particular problem.
Step 1: A light bulb connected between the rails connected to booster A should light. If not, stop. One or both of the wires leading from your booster to the track is not connected to the booster.
Step 2: A light bulb connected between the rails connected to booster B should light. If not, stop. You could have the same problem as in step 1.
Step 3: A light bulb connected between the red rail of booster A and the blue rail of booster B should light. If not, you may not have a good ground between the boosters or you do not have good phasing between boosters. To check phasing, swap the wires going to your track from ONE (1) of the boosters and try this step again.
Step 4: A light bulb connected between the blue rail of booster A and the red rail of booster B should light. If not, you may not have a good ground between the boosters. If step 3 passes, passing this step should just be a confirmation that all is well.
Step 5: A light connected between the red rail of booster A and the red rail of booster B should NOT light. If it does, even glows a little, then either your boosters do not have a good ground between them or the boosters are putting out different voltages. If you need to measure your track's voltage, see the section above on measuring DCC. If your bulb is excessively bright or burns out in a flash, then you probably have a common rail problem. See the section on common rails in the Track Part 2 page of this website. If you have converted an existing DC layout to DCC, this is likely your problem.
Step 6: A light connected between the blue rail of booster A and the blue rail of booster B should NOT light. If it does, even glows a little, then you may have the same problems as described in step 5.
If you are still having problems, are you using boosters from differing manufacturers? They may not play well together.
If you train changes speed as it crosses between booster districts, you may have the boosters set to different output voltages. Consult your booster's manual for instructions on how to properly set the output voltage of your boosters. In some cases, this may be as simple as flipping a switch on the front of your booster.
TROUBLESHOOTING: A Short Between Rails of Track.
How can you have a short on a block of track that has no turnouts or crossings? This sounds far-fetched, but I have seen it twice this past year. The soldered feeders from a bus to BOTH rails shorting everything out. While this sounds like the person was really stupid, it really isn't that hard to do. How many times have you checked the rail on the top is the one you are about to connect a wire to. All you have to do is do this one enough times.
TROUBLESHOOTING: Divide and Conquer Bus Feeder Problems.
Okay, you've spent several hours trying to find a short with an ohm meter. You've given up and now you are going to cut feeders. Start with the first feeder and go down the line. Right? What if you have 16 feeders on a bus and the problem is feeder #14? You have already resolved yourself that this will be the case thanks to Murphy's Law. So you begin at feeder one and start cutting. No! Try something called a binary search instead. Here's how it goes. Follow the example, please, and then we'll get to some practical considerations.
Put your ohm meter or handy beeper in place of the booster. Break the bus in the middle - between feeder #8 and #9. You cut the bus in half. This is the "binary" part of this thing. The short then goes away. Now the "search" begins! Since you have disconnected the meter from #9 thru #16, you know the problem is not with #1 thru #8. So reattach your meter to the bus at #9. Your meter reads a short again.
Divide the bus in the middle again; this time between #12 and # 13. #13 thru #16 are now disconnected and the short goes away. You know the problem is not with #9 thru #12. Reattach the meter at #13. The short is back.
Divide between #14 and #15.
This time the problem stays. It's either #13 or #14. Cut feeder #13. The short is still present. The problem is #14.
So how many cuts did you have to make? Four. If you had started at #1, it would have been fourteen! Imagine the number of cuts saved if you have more than sixteen feeders!!!
Notice if you had 32, or even 64, it would only have been 1 or 2 more cuts respectively. Beats 62 cuts, doesn't it? You can zero in on the problem feeder in just five minutes! Now think about how little time it will take to repair the bus compared with reconnecting 62 feeders!
Now as practical matter, you just hacked up your bus in three places. So perhaps you just do the first two cuts above or whenever you get down to about four feeders. You will definitely need to do a good soldering job in repairing your bus.
Moral, and to avoid hacking up your bus any more than necessary:
One of the beauties of DCC is that except for rail switches, gaps in the track that you didn't put anything in, and any wires underneath that you didn't insulate that might touch, you aren't likely to have wiring problems.
*I don't mean to offend any rail switch manufacturers. It's the nature of the beast, not the quality of your construction. The same applies to real railroads!
INFORMATION: Wiring Australian "Accept" Yard Signals
I was recently asked: "I had a yard on my standard DC powered layout with "Accept" signals. This controls entrance of trains into a yard. With a simple circuit, trains could leave when the light was red, but trains could not enter. Is there an easy way to do this with DCC?"
I suspect the simple circuit was a relay and a diode. Darn simple! Sorry, nothing that simple can be done in DCC or any command control system. I suggest you put a block on either side of the signal. The block behind the signal would have current sensing. This could trigger a Digitrax DS-54 turnout controller or possibly a Wangrow SM-104. The DS-54, and I believe the SM-104 as well, has outputs that can be on for a number of seconds. (The DS-54 can do 12 seconds.) So a departing train could leave using the turnout controller to activate a relay that would energize the block in front of the signal. In the case of the DS-54, the throttle could turn on the block in front of the signal and turn the light green. Again, I feel fairly certain the SM-104 can do this, too.
Some decoders, like the Digitrax decoders, can keep their functions active in the presence of DC. So instead of killing the block in front of the signal completely, use a relay to apply DC. An approaching train, with the appropriate CV set to stop when no DCC signal is present, will stop. The decoders also have a CV that allows the functions, like the headlights, to remain on if DC is present. Some people call this a "break generator."
Copyright by Allan Gartner 1996 - 2019 © All rights reserved. You may print this for your own, personal, non-commercial use. Non-commercial, non-personal reproduction may be requested by visiting www.WiringForDCC.com/writeme.htm . All users, commercial and non-commercial, may link only to this site at www.WiringForDCC.com.
Thanks to all who contribute to this site and the Q&A forum!